← Back to Upcase

Encapsulation vs Extract Class?


(Samnang Chhun) #1

When I am working on implementing functionality of a class, I usually like to have minimum public interface for that class and extract some of detail implementation into private methods, but I too often feel hard to decide either to keep the knowledges in private method or extract those into new classes even I know that currently those new classes aren’t used by anywhere else.

Could you share your guideline/experience on how you decide to choose one over the other?


(Amed Rodriguez) #2

Hey, a concrete example would be helpful to form a better opinion, but what if you start thinking from the Single Responsibility Principle standpoint?


(Andy Waite) #3

Some of the heuristics I use for this:

  • If the private part of the class is significantly larger than the public part, then I treat that a sign that it’s maybe time to extract some objects
  • If the specs are becoming complex, e.g. using many levels of nested contexts or lots of setup code.

(Samnang Chhun) #4

@amedr here is an example https://gist.github.com/samnang/980151587855c151d639 . In this example, I put everything inside my public class interface.